|
|
Post by marshotel on Feb 2, 2024 10:03:29 GMT -5
I think the body of work speaks for itself.
|
|
|
|
Post by MTS on Feb 2, 2024 11:59:06 GMT -5
The problem with looking backward is D’Arg can’t see the impact on the past recruiting on the future roster. Scholarships a locked up and without runoffs and successful portal backfills the future is bleak. Things won’t get better without a change in direction asap. The roster is getting blown up. Siena fans will clutch their pearls but about 10 minutes after Siena is eliminated from the MAAC tournament about 8 to 10 guys are going into the portal some by their own choice and some by not their own choice. Carm might get one more year but he does understand he has to “blow up” the roster. |
|
|
|
Post by hardwood on Feb 2, 2024 13:18:13 GMT -5
The problem with looking backward is D’Arg can’t see the impact on the past recruiting on the future roster. Scholarships a locked up and without runoffs and successful portal backfills the future is bleak. Things won’t get better without a change in direction asap. The roster is getting blown up. Siena fans will clutch their pearls but about 10 minutes after Siena is eliminated from the MAAC tournament about 8 to 10 guys are going into the portal some by their own choice and some by not their own choice. Carm might get one more year but he does understand he has to “blow up” the roster. He can’t slight those 3 for 1 guys. The legacy kids going nowhere, international kids can’t be sent away so how many are really going? The difference makers, that’s all. What little difference they made is questionable but that’s who’s going. Carm’s going to have to bring out his best sales pitch to find the kids homes in D2. |
|
$cott
Assistant Coach
Posts: 5,086
Dislikes:
|
Post by $cott on Feb 2, 2024 14:20:21 GMT -5
The problem with looking backward is D’Arg can’t see the impact on the past recruiting on the future roster. Scholarships a locked up and without runoffs and successful portal backfills the future is bleak. Things won’t get better without a change in direction asap. The roster is getting blown up. Siena fans will clutch their pearls but about 10 minutes after Siena is eliminated from the MAAC tournament about 8 to 10 guys are going into the portal some by their own choice and some by not their own choice. Carm might get one more year but he does understand he has to “blow up” the roster. I don't think it is Carm's choice to blow up the roster. Either the kids want to leave or he's stuck with whoever wants to come back. He can try to politely or not so politely show the kids the door but as we've seen in the past, Siena has never run off a kid that absolutely wanted to return. It is also questionable whether the school would even let him get more than one commit at this point. He's got Jojo Moore in the empty spot and now has the TO spot to fill. I would love to see two kids commit right now and show that they've adapted to the times and will allow recruiting beyond the scholarship limits but I fear they are going to be stuck in the archaic model of never running anyone off and never recruiting beyond your 13 spots which will absolutely be doomed to fail in the NIL era regardless of who is the coach. That was an admirable model when the NCAA was running the show and the kids were in a rough spot, now it's the kids running the show so every scholarship should be treated like a one year deal. |
|
|
|
Post by MTS on Feb 2, 2024 14:36:15 GMT -5
The roster is getting blown up. Siena fans will clutch their pearls but about 10 minutes after Siena is eliminated from the MAAC tournament about 8 to 10 guys are going into the portal some by their own choice and some by not their own choice. Carm might get one more year but he does understand he has to “blow up” the roster. I don't think it is Carm's choice to blow up the roster. Either the kids want to leave or he's stuck with whoever wants to come back. He can try to politely or not so politely show the kids the door but as we've seen in the past, Siena has never run off a kid that absolutely wanted to return. It is also questionable whether the school would even let him get more than one commit at this point. He's got Jojo Moore in the empty spot and now has the TO spot to fill. I would love to see two kids commit right now and show that they've adapted to the times and will allow recruiting beyond the scholarship limits but I fear they are going to be stuck in the archaic model of never running anyone off and never recruiting beyond your 13 spots which will absolutely be doomed to fail in the NIL era regardless of who is the coach. That was an admirable model when the NCAA was running the show and the kids were in a rough spot, now it's the kids running the show so every scholarship should be treated like a one year deal. One of the reasons they’re probably giving Carm one more year is they are allowing him another shot to rebuild the roster. They believe he is a good enough coach to win but he screwed up the roster. When you win 3-6 games something has to change. We’ll see who’s right in April. |
|
$cott
Assistant Coach
Posts: 5,086
Dislikes:
|
Post by $cott on Feb 2, 2024 14:55:10 GMT -5
I don't think it is Carm's choice to blow up the roster. Either the kids want to leave or he's stuck with whoever wants to come back. He can try to politely or not so politely show the kids the door but as we've seen in the past, Siena has never run off a kid that absolutely wanted to return. It is also questionable whether the school would even let him get more than one commit at this point. He's got Jojo Moore in the empty spot and now has the TO spot to fill. I would love to see two kids commit right now and show that they've adapted to the times and will allow recruiting beyond the scholarship limits but I fear they are going to be stuck in the archaic model of never running anyone off and never recruiting beyond your 13 spots which will absolutely be doomed to fail in the NIL era regardless of who is the coach. That was an admirable model when the NCAA was running the show and the kids were in a rough spot, now it's the kids running the show so every scholarship should be treated like a one year deal. One of the reasons they’re probably giving Carm one more year is they are allowing him another shot to rebuild the roster. They believe he is a good enough coach to win but he screwed up the roster. When you win 3-6 games something has to change. We’ll see who’s right in April. Not sure April is going to prove anything. I could see equal chances of 0 returning players or 9 returning players! I just don't know how much say Carm has in that. What he does have a say in is how he fills those open spots. Whether he's returning 0 or 9 he needs a mininum of 4 impact guys and obviously more than that the less returning players there are. |
|
|
|
Post by hardwood on Feb 2, 2024 15:24:40 GMT -5
I don't think it is Carm's choice to blow up the roster. Either the kids want to leave or he's stuck with whoever wants to come back. He can try to politely or not so politely show the kids the door but as we've seen in the past, Siena has never run off a kid that absolutely wanted to return. It is also questionable whether the school would even let him get more than one commit at this point. He's got Jojo Moore in the empty spot and now has the TO spot to fill. I would love to see two kids commit right now and show that they've adapted to the times and will allow recruiting beyond the scholarship limits but I fear they are going to be stuck in the archaic model of never running anyone off and never recruiting beyond your 13 spots which will absolutely be doomed to fail in the NIL era regardless of who is the coach. That was an admirable model when the NCAA was running the show and the kids were in a rough spot, now it's the kids running the show so every scholarship should be treated like a one year deal. One of the reasons they’re probably giving Carm one more year is they are allowing him another shot to rebuild the roster. They believe he is a good enough coach to win but he screwed up the roster. When you win 3-6 games something has to change. We’ll see who’s right in April. Money and lack of admins commitment to hoop is why he gets another year. |
|
|
|
Post by loudonville9 on Feb 28, 2024 19:23:16 GMT -5
|
|
OneIndian
Associate Head Coach
Posts: 10,687
Dislikes:
|
Post by OneIndian on Feb 29, 2024 8:44:37 GMT -5
I don't think it is Carm's choice to blow up the roster. Either the kids want to leave or he's stuck with whoever wants to come back. He can try to politely or not so politely show the kids the door but as we've seen in the past, Siena has never run off a kid that absolutely wanted to return. It is also questionable whether the school would even let him get more than one commit at this point. He's got Jojo Moore in the empty spot and now has the TO spot to fill. I would love to see two kids commit right now and show that they've adapted to the times and will allow recruiting beyond the scholarship limits but I fear they are going to be stuck in the archaic model of never running anyone off and never recruiting beyond your 13 spots which will absolutely be doomed to fail in the NIL era regardless of who is the coach. That was an admirable model when the NCAA was running the show and the kids were in a rough spot, now it's the kids running the show so every scholarship should be treated like a one year deal. One of the reasons they’re probably giving Carm one more year is they are allowing him another shot to rebuild the roster. They believe he is a good enough coach to win but he screwed up the roster. When you win 3-6 games something has to change. We’ll see who’s right in April. They’d fire him in a NY minute if his contract wasn’t an obstacle. |
|
glen
Team Captain
Posts: 1,838
Dislikes:
|
Post by glen on Feb 29, 2024 8:55:21 GMT -5
One of the reasons they’re probably giving Carm one more year is they are allowing him another shot to rebuild the roster. They believe he is a good enough coach to win but he screwed up the roster. When you win 3-6 games something has to change. We’ll see who’s right in April. They’d fire him in a NY minute if his contract wasn’t an obstacle. And who owns the contract negotiations?!?! Whoever did that should be terminated! |
|
|
|
Post by gosaints on Feb 29, 2024 10:43:26 GMT -5
Isn't she out of a job with Saint Rose closing? One would think she'd be looking for a place to land. Don't want to read to much into this but if it turns out to be more that would be great! |
|
bigsaintg
Assistant Coach
Posts: 6,971
Member is Online
Dislikes:
|
Post by bigsaintg on Feb 29, 2024 11:43:30 GMT -5
She needs a job 7/1 I would assume and as great as she is why wouldn’t they interview others and bring in some other perspectives
|
|
orange77
Junior
Posts: 921
Member is Online
Dislikes:
|
Post by orange77 on Feb 29, 2024 12:45:29 GMT -5
She needs a job 7/1 I would assume and as great as she is why wouldn’t they interview others and bring in some other perspectives The article said she will start at Siena on Monday... |
|
skipc
Sophomore
Posts: 596
Dislikes:
|
Post by skipc on Feb 29, 2024 19:57:00 GMT -5
I don't think it is Carm's choice to blow up the roster. Either the kids want to leave or he's stuck with whoever wants to come back. He can try to politely or not so politely show the kids the door but as we've seen in the past, Siena has never run off a kid that absolutely wanted to return. It is also questionable whether the school would even let him get more than one commit at this point. He's got Jojo Moore in the empty spot and now has the TO spot to fill. I would love to see two kids commit right now and show that they've adapted to the times and will allow recruiting beyond the scholarship limits but I fear they are going to be stuck in the archaic model of never running anyone off and never recruiting beyond your 13 spots which will absolutely be doomed to fail in the NIL era regardless of who is the coach. That was an admirable model when the NCAA was running the show and the kids were in a rough spot, now it's the kids running the show so every scholarship should be treated like a one year deal. One of the reasons they’re probably giving Carm one more year is they are allowing him another shot to rebuild the roster. They believe he is a good enough coach to win but he screwed up the roster. When you win 3-6 games something has to change. We’ll see who’s right in April. Good enough coach- based on what? I always felt his strength was recruiting and fell well short coaching up his players. |
|
bigsaintg
Assistant Coach
Posts: 6,971
Member is Online
Dislikes:
|
Post by bigsaintg on Mar 1, 2024 6:54:17 GMT -5
She needs a job 7/1 I would assume and as great as she is why wouldn’t they interview others and bring in some other perspectives The article said she will start at Siena on Monday... I mean interview for John’s replacement when he leaves |
|
